How Some Solar Companies Are Committing MACRS Depreciation Tax Fraud

Solar energy offers homeowners and businesses significant financial incentives, including the federal Investment Tax Credit (ITC) and depreciation benefits for commercial entities. One such benefit is the Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System (MACRS), which allows businesses to recover the cost of solar energy systems through depreciation over a five-year period. This can provide substantial tax savings for legitimate businesses that install solar.

However, some solar companies are misleading homeowners into fraudulently claiming MACRS depreciation by instructing them to set up a business—even when they do not actually operate one. While it is legal for a legitimate business to claim MACRS on a solar installation used for commercial purposes, falsely structuring a personal residence as a business to claim tax benefits is fraud and can lead to serious financial and legal consequences.

This article explores how MACRS works, how some solar companies are abusing it, the risks homeowners face, and how to protect yourself from fraudulent tax schemes.

In This Article:

• What Is MACRS Depreciation & Who Qualifies?
• How Some Solar Companies are Misusing MACRS
• Why Is This Considered Fraud?
• How Homeowners can Protect Themselves

What Is MACRS Depreciation & Who Qualifies?

MACRS depreciation is a tax incentive designed to help businesses recover the cost of certain property investments, including solar energy systems. Under IRS rules, businesses can depreciate the value of eligible solar energy equipment over five years, reducing taxable income and lowering overall tax liability.

To qualify for MACRS depreciation, the IRS requires:

• The solar system to be owned by a business.
• The system must be used for income-producing purposes (e.g., powering a commercial facility or rental property).
• The taxpayer must have a bona fide business operation that generates revenue and reports expenses.

Can Homeowners Claim MACRS?

Generally, homeowners cannot claim MACRS depreciation unless they:

• Own a business and install solar on commercial property.
• Use the solar system for a rental property where they report rental income.
• Operate a home-based business where at least 50% or more of the electricity generated is used for the business.

This means that simply setting up an LLC for tax benefits, without an actual business purpose, does not qualify and could be considered tax fraud.

How Some Solar Companies Are Misusing MACRS

Despite the clear IRS guidelines, some solar installation companies are misleading homeowners by falsely promoting MACRS as a loophole for residential solar systems. They may:

1. Encouraging Homeowners to Create a Business Entity Without a Real Business

Some solar companies advise homeowners to create an LLC, sole proprietorship, or other business entity solely to claim MACRS depreciation. However, unless the homeowner is actually operating a legitimate business, this strategy does not qualify for the tax benefit and could be considered fraudulent. Setting up a business for tax advantages without actual business activity can trigger IRS audits and penalties.

2. Misrepresenting Net Metering as a Business Activity

Another common misleading claim is that selling excess solar energy back to the grid through net metering qualifies as a business activity. While net metering allows homeowners to receive credits for surplus energy sent to the grid, it does not constitute a business operation that qualifies for MACRS. Homeowners should be cautious if a solar company tries to equate net metering with legitimate business income. This is not the case and cannot be considered a business activity that qualifies for MACRS depreciation.

3. Assuring Homeowners That Small Business Tax Fraud Will Go Unnoticed

Some companies try to downplay the risk of IRS audits, falsely assuring homeowners that the IRS won’t investigate small businesses or that claiming MACRS without an actual business is a “gray area.” The reality is that the IRS has clear guidelines on what qualifies as a business expense, and improperly claiming MACRS can result in penalties, interest, and legal repercussions.

4. Pushing Misleading Marketing Messages

Misleading marketing tactics are often used to convince homeowners to falsely claim MACRS. Some common deceptive pitches include:

• “Anyone can qualify for MACRS if they start a solar business!” (False—only legitimate businesses qualify.)
• “You can claim business depreciation just by selling your excess solar power!” (False—net metering does not constitute a business.)
• “We’ll set up your LLC and help you get thousands in tax write-offs!” (Red flag—this implies tax fraud.)

These tactics are designed to entice homeowners into solar contracts under false pretenses, creating potential legal and financial risks. If a solar company mentions these tactics or encourages you to take advantage of MACRS depreciation if you don’t qualify, do not work with that solar company.

Instead, contact a local solar company who understands commercial tax incentives and MACRS depreciation for solar panels. If you live in Oregon, contact Green Ridge Solar. Their solar experts know residential solar and commercial incentives inside-out and can help you apply for every incentive you qualify for. Speak with Green Ridge Solar today!

Why This Is Considered Fraud

The improper use of MACRS depreciation by homeowners who do not own a legitimate business is a direct violation of IRS tax laws and can have severe legal and financial repercussions. While MACRS is designed to benefit businesses by allowing them to depreciate the cost of their solar energy systems, some solar companies are misleading homeowners into believing they can take advantage of this tax benefit by creating a business entity without actually operating a legitimate business. This kind of manipulation not only puts homeowners at risk but also undermines the integrity of tax regulations.

What Constitutes Tax Fraud?

The IRS defines tax fraud as the deliberate misrepresentation or concealment of information to reduce tax liability. This includes knowingly submitting false tax information, misclassifying personal expenses as business expenses, and failing to report accurate income and business activities. When a homeowner claims MACRS depreciation under false pretenses, they are engaging in tax fraud, which can result in significant consequences.

Consequences for Homeowners

If a homeowner falsely claims MACRS depreciation, they may face a variety of repercussions. The IRS can conduct a tax audit to verify the legitimacy of business expenses. If it is determined that the claim was fraudulent, the homeowner will be required to repay the full amount of improperly claimed tax savings, along with accrued interest and penalties. In more serious cases, fraudulent claims can lead to civil penalties or even criminal charges, which could result in substantial fines or legal action.

Consequences for Solar Companies

Solar companies that engage in misleading marketing tactics regarding MACRS depreciation also face serious consequences. These companies may be subject to federal investigations and fines for encouraging tax fraud. Furthermore, engaging in such deceptive practices can result in the revocation of business licenses, loss of credibility, and reputational damage. In some instances, customers who were misled may choose to file lawsuits against the company, further compounding the financial and legal liabilities they may face.

By ensuring homeowners and businesses follow proper tax guidelines, the solar industry can maintain integrity and continue to promote legitimate financial benefits for those who qualify.

How Homeowners Can Protect Themselves

Misleading tax schemes can have serious financial and legal consequences for homeowners. To ensure they are making informed decisions, homeowners should take a proactive approach in evaluating solar companies and their claims about MACRS eligibility. Being aware of common deception tactics and conducting thorough research can prevent costly mistakes.

Evaluating the Legitimacy of MACRS Claims

Before committing to a solar installation, homeowners should ensure they fully understand the qualifications for MACRS depreciation. It is crucial to confirm whether the system truly qualifies under IRS guidelines and whether business ownership is necessary to claim these tax benefits.

To verify that the solar company fully understands how MACRS depreciation works and isn’t misrepresenting the program, homeowners should ask specific questions when consulting with solar companies, such as:

• Does the IRS classify this installation as eligible for MACRS depreciation?
• Do I need to own and operate a legitimate business to claim these benefits?
• Can I consult an independent tax professional before making a decision?

If a solar company discourages seeking external tax advice or provides vague or incorrect answers regarding IRS regulations, this may indicate deceptive practices. Taking the time to consult with a qualified tax professional can help homeowners avoid financial and legal complications later on. You should also contact multiple local solar companies to get a second opinion and verify incentive advice.

If you live in Oregon, contact Green Ridge Solar. Their solar experts know residential solar and commercial incentives inside-out and can help you apply for every incentive you qualify for. Speak with Green Ridge Solar today!

Recognizing Misleading Sales Tactics

Homeowners should be cautious of misleading sales tactics that attempt to misrepresent MACRS eligibility. Some solar companies falsely claim that all residential solar systems qualify, even when the homeowner does not operate a legitimate business. Others may offer to set up an LLC solely to facilitate tax deductions, an action that can lead to IRS scrutiny and penalties.

Another deceptive tactic involves suggesting that selling excess solar energy back to the grid through net metering qualifies as business income, which is not the case. Additionally, companies that dismiss the risks of IRS audits or claim that tax fraud will go unnoticed should raise immediate concerns.

By being aware of these red flags, homeowners can protect themselves from fraudulent schemes and ensure they are making tax-compliant and financially sound decisions regarding solar installations.

Beware of Solar MACRS Depreciation Fraud

The MACRS depreciation incentive is a valuable tool for legitimate businesses investing in solar energy, providing a structured way to recover costs and benefit from tax reductions. However, some unscrupulous solar companies are misleading homeowners into believing they can claim business depreciation on residential solar installations, leading them into potential tax fraud.

To avoid falling victim to these deceptive tactics, homeowners must be vigilant and well-informed. It is crucial to ask detailed questions about MACRS eligibility and thoroughly verify whether their solar installation genuinely qualifies under IRS regulations. Consulting with a tax professional before making any claims can prevent costly mistakes, including audits, penalties, and legal repercussions.

If a solar company aggressively promotes MACRS benefits without discussing the necessary qualifications or pressures homeowners to set up a business entity solely for tax purposes, this should raise immediate red flags. Walking away from such companies and reporting their misleading practices to consumer protection agencies or the IRS can help prevent further financial harm to others.

Investing in solar energy should be a transparent and beneficial process. By ensuring compliance with tax laws and working only with reputable solar providers, homeowners can maximize their benefits without facing unintended legal consequences.

To learn more about MACRS deprecation of solar energy systems, contact Green Ridge Solar. Our solar experts can answer all your questions about solar incentives, tax benefits, and more. We can help navigate commercial solar incentives and hunt down every tax credit, discount, rebate, etc. that you qualify for. Contact us today!

Want to know how much you could save with solar? Use our Solar Calculator to estimate your solar savings.